Accessibility Tools

Need a Knee Surgeon in Detroit, Royal Oak or Grosse Pointe? When Should You Consider Surgery?

Need a Knee Surgeon in Detroit, Royal Oak or Grosse Pointe? When Should You Consider Surgery?
Need a Knee Surgeon in Detroit, Royal Oak or Grosse Pointe? When Should You Consider Surge...

Need a Knee Surgeon in Detroit, Royal Oak or Grosse Pointe? When Should You Consider Surgery?

Your knees carry you up the stairs, through a round of golf and across a parking lot on an icy Michigan morning. When one starts to swell, buckle or ache, you probably want to know whether rest will fix it or whether surgery is in your future. The answer depends on what is actually wrong inside the joint and how well simpler treatments work for you.

Understanding What Is Behind Your Knee Pain

Your knee is where your thighbone, shinbone and kneecap meet, held together by ligaments and cushioned by two C shaped pads of cartilage called menisci. Knee pain can come from any of these structures, so the location, timing and pattern of your symptoms all help narrow the cause.

Injuries

A sudden twist, a fall or a sports collision can tear a ligament, damage a meniscus or dislocate your kneecap. A knee injury usually announces itself with pain, swelling and stiffness, and a rapid onset of both pain and swelling calls for prompt evaluation.

Arthritis

Knee arthritis develops when the smooth cartilage lining the joint wears away. Osteoarthritis occurs most often after age 50, although it can affect younger adults too.1 It is remarkably common. One large study estimated the lifetime risk of symptomatic knee osteoarthritis at about 45%, rising to about 57% after a prior knee injury.2

Other Causes

Tendon inflammation, bursitis, gout and infection can also cause knee pain. Infection in particular needs urgent attention, especially if you have fever with a hot, swollen joint.

Treatment That Comes Before Surgery

For most knee problems, the first plan is nonsurgical, and that plan works well for many knees.

For a Fresh Injury

In the first days after an injury, rest, ice, compression and elevation help control swelling and pain. Many meniscus tears do not need immediate surgery, particularly when your knee is not locking or repeatedly swelling.3

For Arthritis

Care for knee arthritis is built around a few core options, which you can explore in more detail among the nonsurgical knee treatments available:

  • Medication. Ibuprofen, naproxen or acetaminophen can ease pain, as long as your primary care doctor agrees these are safe for you.
  • Exercise. Strengthening your quadriceps and hamstrings improves support around the joint, and lower impact activities such as swimming or cycling keep you active with less stress on the knee.1
  • Weight loss. Each pound you lose takes roughly four pounds of load off your knee with every step.4
  • Injections. Corticosteroid injections can calm inflammation and provide temporary relief.
  • Assistive devices. A cane held in the hand opposite your sore knee reduces strain while walking.

When Surgery Deserves a Closer Look

Surgery is generally considered when your knee keeps limiting your life despite a fair trial of these measures. The exact trigger depends on your diagnosis.

Mechanical Problems After an Injury

A torn ligament that leaves your knee unstable, a meniscus tear that causes true locking, or a fracture may need surgical repair. Your exam and imaging guide that decision.

Arthritis That No Longer Responds

For a degenerative meniscus tear in an arthritic knee, arthroscopy is not automatically the answer. In a randomized trial of adults with a meniscal tear and knee osteoarthritis, improvement at six months was similar after surgery or physical therapy, although 30% of the therapy group eventually chose surgery.5 That finding is a good reason to discuss realistic expectations before any arthroscopy.

When arthritis itself is the problem, replacement becomes the main surgical option. Severe pain or stiffness that limits walking, climbing stairs or rising from a chair, pain at rest, chronic swelling, a bowing deformity and failure to improve with other treatments are all reasons a surgeon may recommend a total knee replacement.6 If arthritis is limited to one part of the joint, a partial knee replacement may be possible instead.

Choosing a Knee Surgeon

Look for a surgeon whose practice focuses on knee and hip conditions, who will walk you through nonsurgical and surgical options alike, and who shares the reasoning behind each recommendation. Knee care is available at Henry Ford Hospital in Detroit, Henry Ford Royal Oak Medical Center and Henry Ford Cottage Medical Center in Grosse Pointe.

Before your visit, write down when your symptoms started, what eases or worsens your pain and which treatments you have already tried. Bring any recent X-rays or MRI images so your evaluation can build on work already done.

Frequently Asked Questions

When should you see a knee surgeon instead of waiting?

See a surgeon promptly for rapid swelling after an injury, a knee that locks or gives way, inability to bear weight, or a hot, swollen joint with fever. For slowly worsening arthritis, an evaluation makes sense once pain limits your daily activities.

Does a meniscus tear always need surgery?

No. Many tears improve with rest, ice, medication and therapy. Surgery is more likely to help a tear that causes locking or keeps your knee swelling.3

Can weight loss really reduce knee pain?

Yes. Research shows that each pound lost removes about four pounds of load from your knee per step, which adds up over thousands of steps a day.4

What is the difference between total and partial knee replacement?

A total knee replacement resurfaces the entire joint. A partial replacement resurfaces only the damaged compartment and is an option when arthritis is limited to one area.7

Where can you find a knee surgeon in Detroit, Royal Oak or Grosse Pointe?

Knee evaluations and surgery are offered at Henry Ford Hospital in Detroit, Henry Ford Royal Oak Medical Center and Henry Ford Cottage Medical Center in Grosse Pointe.

Planning Your Knee Care

Knowing why your knee hurts is the first step toward the right treatment, whether that means a therapy program or a conversation about surgery. If your knee is holding you back, you can schedule a knee evaluation at the location that suits you best.

References

1. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Arthritis of the Knee. OrthoInfo.

2. Murphy L, Schwartz TA, Helmick CG, et al. Lifetime risk of symptomatic knee osteoarthritis. Arthritis Rheum. 2008.

3. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Meniscus Tears. OrthoInfo.

4. Messier SP, Gutekunst DJ, Davis C, DeVita P. Weight loss reduces knee joint loads in overweight and obese older adults with knee osteoarthritis. Arthritis Rheum. 2005.

5. Katz JN, Brophy RH, Chaisson CE, et al. Surgery versus physical therapy for a meniscal tear and osteoarthritis. N Engl J Med. 2013.

6. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Total Knee Replacement. OrthoInfo.

7. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Unicompartmental (Partial) Knee Replacement. OrthoInfo.

Michael A. Charters, MD, is an orthopaedic surgeon who specializes in hip and knee replacement and robotic knee replacement. He also specializes in minimally invasive and revision hip and knee replacement and partial knee replacement. His clinical interests include multimodal pain management and rapid recovery after joint replacement, and his research focuses on improving outcomes. He practices at Henry Ford Hospital in Detroit, Henry Ford Royal Oak Medical Center and Henry Ford Cottage Medical Center in Grosse Pointe.